Why Animals Do Not Make Good Gifts

Animals are not toys. They are sentient beings who, like us, require love and proper care to flourish. Although people who give animals as gifts invariably have good intentions, it is unfair to give an animal to anyone unless you are absolutely certain that the person wants that particular animal as a companion and is willing and able to give a lifetime of proper care.

Children Can Be Cruel

Intentionally or not, sometimes children are cruel to animals. Puppies, kittens, bunnies, chicks, baby ducks, and other young animals are especially vulnerable. Small children may unintentionally torment and/or harm animals, even breaking their fragile bones or causing other fatal injuries.

Adoration may turn to indifference or even hostility when a child loses interest in an animal, who may then go without necessary care. The child’s parents or the adult who gave the child the animal may become impatient and try to “solve” the problem by turning the animal over to a shelter or a pound or – worse – passing the animal on to a series of homes, causing trauma, psychological scarring, and behavioral problems.

Think Before Giving

Adding an animal companion to the family is an important decision. Adopting an animal means making a permanent commitment to care for and spend time with the animal and to provide for him or her in case of one’s absence for the entire life of the animal. Before adopting, consider the time and money involved in proper animal care. Will someone have the time and patience to exercise and housebreak the animal? Is someone prepared to pay for food, accessories (such as toys, grooming supplies, leashes and harnesses, and bedding), inoculations, and veterinary care, including spaying or neutering, flea treatment, worming, and emergency care?

If a family decides to adopt an animal, every member of the family should go to the local shelter together to choose the animal, having already discussed the obligations and long-term commitments involved. It is also necessary to be aware of local, state, and federal regulations that govern animal “ownership.” Most communities require annual licensing for dogs and cats, and many require that animals be on the custodian’s property at all times and that they be spayed or neutered.

Too Few Happy Endings

Animal shelters are filled beyond capacity with homeless animals. Many of these are former “pets” who were easily acquired but, for one reason or another, didn’t fit into someone’s lifestyle. Whether they are dogs, cats, rabbits, gerbils, chicks, ducks, or goldfish, some people regard them as expendable. Unwanted animals are often passed from home to irresponsible home as the novelty of having an animal wears thin at each successive place. Many people experience little or no guilt when turning an animal over to an overburdened humane society or animal-control agency that is likely filled to capacity with other abandoned animals. Many animals are simply abandoned on the road or in the yard when the family moves away. Dogs who were dumped at Badlands National Park were trapped in steel-jaw leghold traps set by park rangers; most had to be euthanized, and the lone survivor’s leg had to be amputated.(1)
What You Can Do

Don’t ever give an animal as a gift! If you have discussed the idea with the prospective recipients and know that they have the time, willingness, ability, and resources to properly care for an animal and make that serious commitment, consider offering them a gift certificate from the local animal shelter.

If you attend a fair, flea market, or other event at which animals are being given away, educate those who are responsible. If people are offering free kittens or puppies, for example, explain the risks of giving animals to unknown passersby – some people sell dogs and cats to laboratories or dealers, and others abuse, neglect, or abandon them. Feel free to share with these people any print-outs of our factsheets.

If a business is giving away animals as a promotion, complain to sponsors, explaining what can happen to animals who are not taken by caring, capable people. Get sponsors to save lives by giving away stuffed toy animals instead.

In 2004, legislation was introduced in the U.K. that, if passed, will make it illegal to give fish as “prizes” or sell animals to children under the age of 16 and will also ensure that guardians provide a “suitable environment” for animals.(2) In Italy, animal-welfare laws dictate fines and jail sentences for many crimes against animals, including dumping.(3) In the U.S., existing laws provide woefully inadequate protection for animals. Contact local, county, and state officials about introducing and passing more substantive animal-protection laws (see HelpingAnimals.com for more information), and get involved with animal rights and welfare groups that can provide educational materials and help stop public animal giveaways.

References1) Jomay Steen, “Badlands Officials Revise Trap Policies,” Rapid City Journal, 13 Jul. 2004.
2) “Overhaul for Animal Welfare Laws,” BBC News, 14 Jul. 2004.
3) “New Animal-Protection Laws Passed Amid Protest,” ANSA English Media Service, 8 Jul. 2004.